Saturday, April 09, 2005

Who needs a reformation?

If I had a penny for every time I heard that “Islam needs a reformation with its own Martin Luther”…well you know how the rest of the line goes. Even if we ignore those who utter such words, such a proposition needs to be confronted and corrected.
I personally do not sponsor to the monkey-see monkey-do approach of many proggies who believe that the answer to all of humanity’s ills lies in a pre-packaged western one-size-fits-all solution. You definitely won’t find a solution feasting on a bagel and cup of frapachino at Starbucks.
Indeed, to demand a “reformation” in Islam following in the footsteps of the Protestant “reformation” of Europe reveals a blatant ignorance and arrogance about the history of that event. Were Muslims burning books in a bonfire ? Did they murder untold numbers of woman accusing them of witchcraft ? How about burning heretics at the stake ? Did Muslims initiate and execute murderous Crusades ? Certainly not, this in itself should be enough for a sensible person to reject calls for reformation. If I remember right, Muslims did not alter themselves or their faith to liberate Jerusalem, they united under the banner of Islam to expel the crusaders. So what explains the present ills of the Muslims ? The answer lies in what made the Muslims of the past victorious over their enemies despite overwhelming odds, an unshakable belief in the Holy Quran and the Sunnah of the Prophet (s.a.w). It should come as no surprise that as Muslims embraced the dunya, the unseen help of Allah was denied to them. Indeed, the failures of the Arab and Islamic world today is nothing less than the absolute failure of progressivism whether it cast itself as Kemalism, Nasserism, Marxism, Ba’athism, Pan-Arabism, or any other imported and imposed notion of “progress.” You would think that anyone with common sense would ditch such failed systems of thought and governance by now instead of carrying on about religious reformation like a trained parrot in a cage.
Oh we’ve had our share of reformers, mind you. Under the guidance and protection of the British, Mirza Ghulam Ahmed declared himself a prophet to the Muslims of India, declaring all those who didn’t accept him as kafirs. To this day the Ahmediya cult enjoys a privileged status in England. Over in North America, Noble Drew Ali and Elijah Pool declared themselves as messengers of the Supreme. The NOI freely operates in the US, with neither its activities or theology under any real scrutiny. Cant let the “angry black mooslim” stereotype go to waste can we? One does not need a RAND corporation report to see that there have been numerous attempts by the enemies of Islam to create and promote schisms in the name of “reformation.” Today we have a new generation of “reformers,” a veritable gooftroop of charlatans, opportunists, and liars falling over themselves trying to jump on the moderate/progressive bandwagon. Whether it’s Pakistan’s bumbling semi-literate General-in-chief with his “enlightened moderation,” or the regressive definition for Muslims put forth by a group of pseudo-intellectual leftist extremists in cyberspace, “reformation” is in, common sense and honesty are out. And you cant have a good ol’ reformation without your very own Martin Luther, and there’s no shortage of candidates. The gamut runs from catamite Canadian supporters of terrorism to well to do academics who like to fancy themselves as “Muslim Kissingers.”
There’s plenty of talk about revitalizing intellectual thinking and grand ijtihad like schemes coming from the usual suspects. These are really just convenient buzz words and catchy phrases, which in reality bear little resemblance to their true objectives. Who says intellectual tradition and philosophical inquiry are dead within the ummah? Ever heard of the late Sheikh Ahmed Deedat? How about Dr.Zakir Naik, a man whose ability to debate and present facts has scared off the likes of Taslima Nasrin and other paper tigers? I could go on about the Maryam Jamilahs, Haroon Yahyas, Hamza Yusufs of this ummah but I think the point has been made.
Haskalah was defined as 18th century Jewish “enlightenment,” a movement amongst Europe’s Jewish elite to assimilate their community. Theodore Herzl, the founder of zionism even proposed the mass conversion of Jews to Christianity, in essence rejecting the “otherness” of Jews and the acceptance of their “Europeaness.” This defines a key part of zionist thought which identifies Judaism through race rather than religious affiliation. While Muslim proggies haven’t yet proposed religious conversion, they are following the same path of assimilation through appeasement. Perhaps they forgot what happened to Europe’s Jews.


Blogger Ginny said...

Assalamu alaikum, Mashallah, what a wonderful post! I don't have anything to add to it, just that it's very well written... Take care...

3:19 PM  
Blogger Abdul-Halim V. said...


I agree with alot of the sentiment of the post. The Reformation was actually a very divisive process in Christian history and many of the alleged "Reform" movements in Islam, also have the potential to be very divisive and harmful.

But at the same time, we still need to I think recognize that the ummah right now isn't where it should be and that we need to make efforts to get it there.

So if we don't call it "reformation" what DO we call it? What direction should we be going in?

8:48 PM  
Blogger DrMaxtor said...

The problems in the ummah I believe have to do with a lack of practice and the introduction of nihilism from the colonial experience. What we need is a "restoration" movement. Its easy for me to say this but the answers were given to us a long time ago.

1:23 AM  
Blogger Shakir_Eye said...

Assalaam 'alaikum,

Great post, and love the whole blog. Just a note: as far as I know, Shaykh Ahmad Deedat is still alive, though ill... have you heard otherwise?

8:09 PM  
Blogger cahincaha said...

Salam alaikum

Very good post. I think though that the words are very important and can bear different meanings. I'm very ignorant, but it seems to me that the wahabbi movement claimed in its time (and still claims) to be a "reform" movement, meaning back to the basics as the Reform was vs. catholicism. My point is that "reform" or "reformism" are some of these words you can understand the way you want. Yet it has a "positive" appeal (who would be against reform ? Is'nt reform supposed to be good etc...). Sorry about my english and sorry if I'm not clear, but what I mean is that under the word "reform" many different views make their claims. That's why I guess it's best to stick to tradition. But then again who is closest to tradition? I'm not talking about the "progressive" muslims (we don't really have them here).

6:59 AM  
Blogger Ann said...

Assalaamu alaikum,

Islam doesn't need to be reformed, updated, or modernized. But we need to reform ourselves to be better Muslims...

2:05 PM  
Blogger DrMaxtor said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

5:26 PM  
Blogger Kashif said...

assalaamu alaikum

Good post. If only the progressives realised that it was only in the old days, when we held onto traditional Islamic values, that the ummah was united and strong. Its only when we've left Islam and tried to be more 'progressive' that the situation has worsened.

4:01 AM  
Blogger altaf said...

"While Muslim proggies haven’t yet proposed religious conversion, they are following the same path of assimilation through appeasement. Perhaps they forgot what happened to Europe’s Jews."

Salaam exactly so - a similar question i'd ask is "who benefits from such a reformation as advocated by PMUNA MWU" And to also follow the money - who is funding these "reformations" and where is the ideological content coming from?

This will help us gain an institutional/structural understanding of how these newly minted groups are operating.


4:31 PM  
Blogger thabet said...

Tajdid and islah are not new to Islamic history. Ever heard of Sirhindi, Shah Wali Allah and Usman dan Fodio? I'm sure you have.

Obviously the concern is what _kind_ of "reformation" is proposed by self-identified "progressives". All too easily people invoke "ijtihad" to say "we (Muslims) can be like you (liberals) too". This is jusy lazy and sloppy thinking.

Perhaps it is better if Muslim identify their own "goals" of "progress" (the current manifestation is the outgrowth of an idea invented in 18th-century England). These may overlap "progressive" ideals of Europe/N. America (e.g. distribution of wealth) or may not (e.g. reductionist materialism).

assalamu 'alaykum

2:12 PM  
Blogger X said...

What I find amusing is how PMUNA/MWU can have the audacity to assume that they have any credibility at all.

It seems like a gathering of confused individuals who's only support comes from each other.

9:40 AM  
Blogger SAADI EL said...


Islam & Greetings with complete blessing from Father God Allah.

It gives me sheer joy and great pleasure to be able to present to you an outline of what will be the first of its kind to take place in Atlanta Georgia. The “Islamic Forum 2005”, were as varies Islamic groups and religious organizations can come under “UNITY” regardless of cultural differences, “For customs dose NOT alter the nature of TRUTH” for if we truly believe that Allah is Allah and there is no other God but Allah, then the question becomes were can we work together.

For has you can bear witness to there being a great misconception about our religious faith of “Islam” here in the Americas. Islam has been deemed as “evil” and those who practices the faith of Islam has being militant and anti-divine. For this is the very reason why this forum is so important, it is to bring light and understanding of our beautiful faith of Islam and our oneness with All Mighty Allah as well as coming in unity were we can bring greater good and form unification under the all seeing eye of Allah.

This forum is not to debate cultural differences nor further cause a greater misunderstanding of the faith of Islam, for if such a debate were to take place let it be within the best of our faith and creed by those who are recognized as being Islamic scholars who would be fitted best to speak on such issues. For our main objective is to speak on the many issues we face here in America living as Muslims and Moslems.

There are hundreds and thousands of learning intuitions, hospitals and businesses that fall under the cloak of Christianity and yet with the growing numbers of Afro-Americans tuning to Islam we should set the wheels in motion to pull our resources and economical threads to create a non-penetrable rope were as it can be cast out into the cares of the world to pull up out of its murky ethers race pride, morality, family structure, and the love for humanity within our communities and our fellow Bothers and Sisters. Let our Crescent and Star be the light that shines the path of those who are lost and without, placing them back into the oneness with All Mighty Allah.

By this we can set in motion an “Islamic television network” similar to that of TBN,
(A Christian television network). As well as Islamic radio, publications, locale and national news networks to give light on our growing Islamic communities here in America. Learning institutions, medical care, childcare, etc. We can shed light on our lack of economical powers within our own communities while at the same time giving life to a pliable solution. We will bring into focus the displaced view and corruption of family and morality, while putting within its place a pillar of decency and family structure for which our communities can lean upon for support. We shall speak on the things that are a venomous virus that has been placed deep within our communities to kill off our Brothers, Sons and Fathers while causing our Sisters, Daughters and Mothers to jump ship and find refuges on some foreign vessel were as all evil is placed in there hearts and minds.
Its time for us to regain that of which was stripped from us and to honor our Forefathers and Foremothers and placed back before us our Divine Creed and Principles. I cannot see any outside oppositions for and event of this nature to take place, for if it shall come it will be only from those who are within the Islamic faith who would rather turn their backs on their fellow Brothers and Sisters and keep the ignorance of the unbelievers continually active.

While moving within the sprit of Allah, if you are interested in participating in this most necessary of forums we truly encourage you to contact us at the information below. Though this conference is FREE to participate we are asking for sponsorship and donations, for all that is collect will be put towards the accumulate cost of this event and any products and or monies that is left over will go towards the next Islamic forum and or to the support and growth of the continuance of our works in uplifting fallen humanity.

If you are an Islamic Leader or Teacher, Community Activists, Political Leader, Educator, Business Owner, Healthcare Provider, we ask that you contact us to take part in this most needed and very necessary “Islamic Forum” let your voice and words vibrate the power of positive change which will be the force to hammer down the un-moveable
ties of “UNITY” within the beautiful faith of ISLAM!. Were in the process of putting together the most powerful 12 panelists to take their place on stage to demonstrate in the highest of; Spirituality, Intellectually and Morally the issues that face our Islamic communities with solidified solutions in bring about change and unification.

The date and time of this event is set for October 1st 2005 at the Art Exchange Building 750 Kalb street, Atlanta Georgia at 2pm (Provided that the responses of participation along with donations are great and accounted for on or before August 1st the location and time will change to accommodate the growing number of participation, (we will try to hold to the same date). Promotions of this event will start August 15th 2005, which by then the date, time and location will be set in stone. This letter is being sent out to stir up the hearts and minds in getting a favorable response, welcomed sponsorships and early donations.

Musical entertainment would be an added pleasure for the beginning, during intermission and towards the end of the event.
DJ, Live music and spoken word, if you are someone processing these wonderful blessed talents and find the “Islamic Forum” to be a worthy cause to donate your gifts we would like for you to contact us.

We look forward in coming under the Crescent & Star with All Mighty Allah approval embrace under the Shari'ah of Islam: Love, Truth, Peace, Freedom and Justice

May Allah bless you and yours.Z

Your Sister in the faith of Islam
Sheikess Yssis Saadi El / CEO of Mother Is Calling©

For registration and inquiries please contact us:

Mother Is Calling
P.O. Box 161986
Atlanta GA 30321
(404) 664-2204, fax (404) 752-1339

Donations can be submitted via Check or Money Order (please do not send cash through the mail) to Mother Is Calling at address above. A Papal donation button will be setup on If you wish to drop off cash donations you can drop them off at The Moorish Science Temple of America, Temple #5 under the leadership of Gov.Mahdi Shabazz El. At the Art Exchange Building 750 Kalb Ave on Sundays from 2:30 to 5PM.

All donation or tax deductible, a pond request of your cash or time services you will receive a receipt of your donations.

Vendors are welcome, we ask that you contact us at the information above.

This event will be sponsored in part by:
Mother Is Calling©Productions Promotions & Event Planning in association with the 1928 portion of The Moorish Science Temple of America, Blackwood Entertainment Productions©,

1:56 PM  
Blogger SAADI EL said...


1:57 PM  
Blogger DrMaxtor said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

9:19 PM  
Blogger DrMaxtor said...

I dont think there is anything to "unite us by" Saadi El. Just what th heck is "father god Allah" ? Pseudo-Islamic cultist propaganda is what it is.

9:35 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home